Eggar Insurance Agency - Serving Northern Illinois and Wisconsin

Get a Quick Quote

Saint Charles Office

Quotes: (630) 463-6055
Service: (630) 225-9325
2020 Dean St, Suite J
St Charles, IL 60174

Lincolnshire Office

Quotes: (847) 607-6656
Service: (847) 607-6610
101 Schelter Rd, Unit 101A
Lincolnshire, Illinois 60069

The Eggar Difference: 10 Reasons Why People Choose and Stay with Eggar Insurance!

Justin Eggar & Katlyn Eggar - Eggar Insurance Agency

Here at Eggar Insurance Agency, we are intent on being more than the run-of-the-mill insurance agency. We are committed to a very high level of customer service. With two locations in Illinois – Geneva & Lincolnshire – we are capable of providing you with the best insurance experience whenever and wherever you are. We are absolutely committed to making your insurance experience smooth, stress-free, and gratifying.

As a Personal Financial Representative in Geneva and Lincolnshire, I know many local families. My knowledge and understanding of the people in this community help me provide customers with an outstanding level of service. I look forward to helping families like yours protect the things that are important your family, home, car and more. I can also help you prepare a strategy to achieve your financial goals. I’m proud to work with a company who’s been serving satisfied customers for over 70 years. I can offer quality insurance that is affordable and provide easy access for you to contact me in person, over the phone, or through my website – wherever and whenever you need. Both Allstate and I know how important price and service are for a long-lasting relationship.

Here are 10 qualities about Eggar Insurance Agency that set us apart:

  • We have been ranked in the top 1% of agencies in the Midwest
  • Our agency was honored with the Inner Circle Elite title
  • We are a full service agency, providing numerous types of policies: home, auto, renter’s, business, umbrella, life, recreational, and more
  • Everytime you call us, you speak to a licensed insurance professional who cares for you – not a call center
  • We provide complimentary family protection reviews to ensure your needs are met
  • Automatic Discount Monitoring – we are always looking for discount opportunities for you
  • Claim Satisfaction – our client’s satisfaction in a claim is ranked substantially higher than the industry average
  • A+ AM Best Rating – we are financially stable and you can count on our agency being here when you need us
  • We guarantee your Privacy – our agency does not share your information with anyone
  • Money Back Guarantee – if you’re not 100% satisfied, we will refund the balance of your premium directly back to you!

What our clients are saying about us

“Justin is not the typical agent. Justin put the needs of the clients first, with his people skill emotional intelligence and honesty he has the ability to listen and empathize with clients on a deeper level in order to understand their needs. Justin is an expert in his field and it’s apparent from the array of comprehensive selection of product and services that he understand and offers to his clients.”
Yvette Busha, Google+ Profile
“As I read the other comments, I see that Eggar is consistent with their customers. I have to say that Justin is the best. He made sure I qualified for every discount and followed through with making sure I received the discounts. I am down $200 from my original homeowners quote and am beyond happy with Eggar’s.”
Angela Fern, Google+ Profile
“I have had my auto and renters policy with Eggar Allstate for about a year now. Justin and Katlyn go out of their way to make sure you receive the right policy, all the discounts, and the best service all around. In addition to running a great agency, they are very warm, friendly people. It’s a pleasure to know them. I wouldn’t want to buy insurance from anyone else!”
Michael Windham, Google+ Profile
“The Eggars had a booth set up at a local 5k and I bumped into them, I was so blown away by their candor and warmth that I called the following Monday to get a quote! I had been over-paying on my car and home by $1,000 a year! I couldn’t believe it, since I had been quoted by another company so recently. I also love that they are open on Saturdays because I am so busy during the week.”
Denise Croft, Google+ Profile
“I had a renters policy and they contacted me to let me know that I would save money if I bundled it with my auto! I’m a young adult and I’m paying off college loans so every bit helps. They really make me feel like a special client and they are always so positive and upbeat on the phone!”
Ellen Kamps, Google+ Profile
“Eggar Allstate was so helpful and nice. I actually feel like I have a personal agent, as opposed to when I was with another name-brand agency that just referred me to a call-center any time I had to file a claim or adjust my policy. They are even there on Saturdays.”
Shreya Aalla, Google+ Profile
“You really are in good hands with Eggar AllState. They are great people and people you can trust. They are very involved in the community as well. Come see them at the Geneva Classic Car Show every Thursday night July thru August. I highly recommend!”
Cheryl Schermerhorn, Google+ Profile

Homeowners Insurance

A home is one of the largest investments that we make. Knowing that, it is crucial to have the the appropriate amount of insurance for your home and your possessions. It is also very important to have the correct liability exposure for your area. Our insurance professionals can help you determine what exactly fits your needs and tailor your insurance for you. One size does not fit all in insurance!

Car Insurance

Car Insurance

Car insurance is not just important, it is the law. Aside from being required if you own a vehicle, car insurance is vital for protecting you, your family, and your assets. Having a comprehensive policy review can make sure that your are doing just that - without it, you may not be protecting yourself from liability exposure or the loss of your vehicle in an accident. Get a complimentary insurance quote and review your coverage levels today!


Life Insurance

Losing loved ones is one of the most difficult experiences that we go through. The tragic truth however, is that it is a reality for all of us. In such a case, a life insurance policy makes sure that your family is not left with any pressing financial burdens. Ensure that your family will be financially protected today by starting a life insurance policy. It is never too late, until it is too late.

Business Insurance

Business Insurance

As a small business owner, I know that choosing your business insurance can be overwhelming. Together, we can discuss the appropriate types of insurance policies that best fit your business. Whether it be General Liability, Business Owners Policy, Workers Compensation, or the several other types of business policies, here at Eggar Insurance, we have the professional expertise and financial wisdom for protecting your business. Don’t leave your business insurance in the hands of a novice!

RV Insurance | Boat Insurance | ATV Insurance

Recreational Insurance

Do you like motorsports and recreational vehicles? We do too! In order to make sure that our toys are fully protected from damage or loss, they need to be insured. Whether you own jet skis, boats, ATVs, or other recreational vehicles, here at Eggar Insurance we have the expertise and know-how to make sure that your recreational vehicles are protected. Make sure that your fun time stays fun by insuring the protection of your toys.

Umbrella Insurance Policies

Umbrella Insurance

Umbrella coverage is a hidden gem in the insurance field. Umbrella policies insure that in the event of tragic mishap, you have enough coverage to insure that you cannot be sued for all of your assets. This coverage is not just important for higher income earners, but also for people who are actively saving for retirement and accumulating assets.

The Eggar Insurance Insider News

7 Ways to Save on Car Insurance

Over the last 10 years auto insurance has become commoditized primarily by direct writers who want the consumer to purchase this valuable coverage based on price rather than what it can actually do for you. The commercials direct you to the company’s website but then you are on your […]

  • shutterstock_141044422-cropped

Cost Saving Tips for Homeowner’s Insurance

I’ve been seeing an uptick in clients coming in for quotes and paying too much for the coverage options they need lately. So much so that it’s actually shocking how much they’ve saved simply by taking into account these quick and easy, albeit huge cost-saving, tips when choosing their insurance […]

  • shutterstock_174927194-cropped

Cheap Car Insurance: Making your Insurance $$ Count

You’re here and you are researching how to make your insurance dollars really work for you. Chances are you are pretty savvy and know that with a bit of effort you can make smart insurance choices. Fortunately, you came to the right place today.

Let me tell you a little […]

  • shutterstock_160214216-cropped

Credit Agencies and Your Good Name

Hey guys, I’ve recently seen an increase in clients asking about their premiums being higher than they need to be due to discrepancies on their credit reports. I’m here with some quick advice that everyone should follow as any negative information on your credit report can harm more than just […]