Justin Eggar
Justin EggarLincolnshire Agency Owner
Justin grew up in the Fiji Islands while his parents were missionaries and lived just outside of a village in Valelevu on the main island of Viti Levu. After leaving Fiji, he joined the Navy and was able to enjoy wonderful duty stations in Iceland and Italy. In 2002, he received an honorable discharge from the Navy and spent a year back in the Fox River Valley where he attended ECC for a year. Justin finished up his undergrad at Liberty University in VA in 2006 and began work for the American Institute of CPAs. In 2009, Katlyn and Justin married and thought that there was no better place to live and raise a family than in the tri-cities. They opened their agency in 2011 and are one of the fastest growing new agencies in Illinois.
Katlyn Eggar
Katlyn EggarGeneva Agency Owner
Katlyn is co-owner and business development manager for Eggar Insurance. She was born and raised in North Carolina, and has a background in retail management. Prior to opening an agency with Justin, Katlyn worked for a company called Origins, an Estee Lauder brand. During her management tenure with Origins, Katlyn won awards for having the highest gross sales of any employee at Origins. One of the primary reasons for her success is her drive to give customers a best in class service experience. She has a strong desire to raise the bar for what customers expect and receive from their insurance agency. Katlyn manages part of the team at Eggar Insurance and her experience is vital in the success of the company.

Our Valuable Team Members

Matt Del Guidice
Matt Del GuidiceLicensed Insurance Agent
Matt is responsible for consulting with customers regarding their insurance to ensure that they are properly protected. He is also essential on one-on-one communication with our clients. Matt currently is enrolled in college and is on the board of directors for the local railroad museum. On the weekends, he enjoys riding his motorcycle in the nice weather.
Katy Smart
Katy SmartClient Care Coordinator
Katy comes to us all the way from Santa Rosa, California. With a BA in Communication from Fresno Pacific University and a minor in Intercultural Studies, she brings her enthusiastic and meticulous nature to further our five-star customer service guarantee. She just moved up the road to Wheaton with her husband, and in her spare time she enjoys reading, exercising, crafts and antiquing.
David Del Guidice
David Del GuidiceCustomer Account Representative
David recently joined the Eggar Insurance Agency as a Customer Account Representative. He is currently getting his degree in psychology, with a minor in mathematics. David was born and raised in the Geneva area. He spends most of his free time playing music and has played at most of the big Chicago area venues with his Band.
Kaity Paeth
Kaity PaethClient Care Coordinator
Kaity is a Geneva, IL native and was born and raised in the Fox River Valley. She recently graduated with a BA in Social Work from Aurora University. Kaity brings a positive and energetic charisma to the agencies client care team. Outside of the great work she does at Eggar Allstate, Kaity likes to spend her free time reading, running and enjoying family.

Eggar Insurance in the community!

  • The Eggar Insurance Agency helping to support the Lake Villa Timberwolves youth football team!